Autobayng News Team
Are Formula 1 fans watching an authentic competition or an increasingly rigged racing show?
Some have claimed for years that F1 has added too many artificial means to create closer racing. But in 2026 those accusations have become noticeably louder.
Formula 1 CEO Stefano Domenicali reacted with incomprehension when it was put to him that the series’ new rules have created “artificial” overtaking.
“Overtaking, some people are saying is artificial,” he said. “What is artificial? Overtaking is overtaking.”
At the opposite end of the debate, Max Verstappen said last weekend his experience of racing in the Nuerburgring 24 Hours made him realise F1 has drifted too far away from authentic motor racing.
“I’ve been racing different kinds of cars, especially last week, that remind me how pure motorsport can be and how great the racing can be,” he said.
But these ideas of ‘pure’ and ‘artificial’ racing mean different things to different people. When you watch F1 today, does it feel too faked?
For
Artificiality is everywhere in F1. The incomprehensible racing, where drivers swap positions from lap to lap for no obvious reason, is just the tip of the iceberg.
The FIA changes the limits on engine performance between rounds to engineer close racing. They will go further in Monaco, forbidding the use of active aerodynamics and limiting engine power to cut top speeds.
The purity of competition between the engineers has gone, too. Aerodynamic development is handicapped based on championship position and the ADUO gives a boost to struggling engine manufacturers. This is now a show, not a sport.
Against
The hand-wringing over ‘artificiality’ misses the point: in an era when F1 is trying to sell itself as “the biggest sport entertainment in the world”, it has to provide closer racing, regardless of how it is produced.
Are those watching concerned about whether they are watching a pure competition or one that is increasingly sculpted by the rules to guarantee frequent changes of position? Some may hate ‘yo-yo racing’ but others welcome it.
Far from diminishing F1, the competition has become better because it has relaxed its attitude towards the kind of ‘pure racing’ Verstappen craves. In that respect, there’s no such thing as ‘too artificial’.
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and
I say
One of my favourite early memories of watching F1 was seeing Gerhard Berger and Nigel Mansell’s fight for second place in the Mexican Grand Prix in 1990. First Berger nipped past Mansell, but the pair remained close, and at the dauntingly fast Peraltada curve Mansell incredibly went around the outside of his rival to reclaim the race.
Passing and re-passing doesn’t automatically mean artificial racing. But the difference between what F1 was then and what it is now is huge. Back then, Berger and Mansell were fighting on a level playing field: if I saw the same today I would just assume Mansell had benefited from his Overtake Mode.
At that time Berger’s Honda engine was a dominant force in F1, but within two years they were being beaten by Renault. Not because Renault got help from the rules, but because they built a better engine. Today team principals sit in press conferences agreeing about how the rules need to be changed again to give Honda even more help to catch up.
F1’s increasingly contrived rules have tainted every aspect of the competition with artificiality. When one driver passes another, or one team suddenly improves their car, did that happen entirely because of their own effort and talent – or partly because the rules helped them?
Who knows. And, therefore, who cares?
You say
Has Formula 1 become too artificial? Would the competition be less enjoyable if it was ‘purer’? Cast your vote below and have your say in the comments.
Do you agree Formula 1 is “too artificial”?
- No opinion (0%)
- Strongly disagree (5%)
- Slightly disagree (8%)
- Neither agree nor disagree (5%)
- Slightly agree (20%)
- Strongly agree (63%)
Total Voters: 102
Loading …
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and
A RaceFans account is required in order to vote. If you do not have one, register an account here or read more about registering here. When this poll is closed the result will be displayed instead of the voting form.
Debates and polls
- Poll: Has the time finally come for Hamilton to hang up his helmet?
- Should Formula 1 drivers be penalised for failing to “respect the sport”?
- Red Bull already has a ‘junior’ B-team – should Mercedes be allowed to have the same?
- Should F1 change tracks or racing guidelines to tackle dangers in 2026 rules?
- Is Formula 1’s double race cancellation a blessing in disguise?
Published by
Keith Collantine
Lifelong motor sport fan Keith set up RaceFans in 2005 – when it was originally called F1 Fanatic. Having previously worked as a motoring journalist, Keith began running the site full-time in 2010, achieving a long-held ambition to dedicate his full attention to his passion for motor racing. View all posts by Keith Collantine
