Alpine request Right of Review hearing over penalty which cost Gasly third place

Alpine request Right of Review hearing over penalty which cost Gasly third place

Alpine has asked the FIA to review the speeding penalties which cost Pierre Gasly third place in the Monaco Grand Prix.

“After the result of today’s Monaco Grand Prix, BWT Alpine Formula 1 Team can confirm it has requested a Right of Review from the FIA following the penalties applied for pit lane speeding,” said the team in a statement.

Gasly said he was “heartbroken” by the result.

“I don’t have the words,” he told Sky. “I have too much emotions to process.”

“I just can’t get my head around what happened. It just doesn’t sound fair.

“I’ve been, triple-checking with the team, they set the right speed in the car. On both occasions, I’ve put the pit limiter [on] way before the line.”

He was one of five drivers who was penalised for breaking the pit lane speed limit during the race, but the only one to do so twice. Along with the other four drivers he initially broke the limit by 0.1kph, but on the second time he was 0.4kph over.

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and

Gasly said he was “200% sure” he did not exceed the pit lane speed limit on either occasion. “I know I haven’t done anything wrong,” he said.

He was deeply disappointed to miss out on his and Alpine’s first podium finish since the 2024 Brazilian Grand Prix.

“We were working so hard for this moment,” he said. “In 10 years I do this, 10 years, I try to grab every opportunity. Five podiums, which is nothing, in my career and we passed the road in third position in front of all the French people and it gets taken away from us so right now I just don’t know what to say.”

Gasly appeared unaware of his penalty when he took the chequered flag. He initially shouted “P3!” and punched the air in celebration but was told “wait, wait” by his race engineer.

Any further communications which may have occured between them were not broadcast. Although Gasly continued to hold his arms aloft for much of his victory lap, he did not stop at the ‘P3’ board when he returned to the pit lane.

The two Alpine drivers accounted for half of the six pit lane speeding penalties which were issued. McLaren’s Oscar Piastri, Ferrari’s Lewis Hamilton and Mercedes’ George Russell all collected penalties. The latter suggested a “software problem” may have been responsible and visited the stewards during the red flag suspension to discuss the matter.

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and

Alpine executive consultant Flavio Briatore said he the team “strongly disagrees” with Gasly’s penalties and believes they have good grounds to contest them. “These penalties were inflicted to at least four teams on the grid, which makes it a strong case for review,” he said. “As such, we have requested a Right of Review with the FIA.”

Gasly also had a close encounter with Lewis Hamilton on his return to the pits. The Alpine driver was travelling quickly when he arrived at Massenet and had to slow down rapidly to avoid hitting the Ferrari.

F1 Right of Review requests since 2019

The last team to instigate a Right of Review hearing was Williams following the Dutch Grand Prix last year. Although they succeeded, the success rate for teams with this form of protest is only 28%:

Date of decision Team Event Incident Outcome
21/6/2019 Ferrari Canadian GP Sebastian Vettel rejoined the track in an unsafe fashion Failed
5/7/2020 Red Bull Austrian GP Lewis Hamilton failed to slow for yellow flags Succeeded
2/5/2021 Alfa Romeo Emilia Romagna GP Kimi Raikkonen failed to re-establish the correct restart order Failed
29/7/2021 Red Bull British GP Lewis Hamilton given a 10-second penalty for colliding with Max Verstappen (Red Bull sought harsher penalty) Failed
9/8/2021 Aston Martin Hungarian GP Sebastian Vettel’s car disqualified for being underweight Failed
19/11/2021 Mercedes Brazilian GP Max Verstappen forced Lewis Hamilton off the track Failed
28/10/2022 Haas United States GP Haas submitted protest against Fernando Alonso too late Succeeded
19/3/2023 Aston Martin Saudi Arabian GP Fernando Alonso failed to serve a five-second time penalty correctly Succeeded
18/4/2023 Ferrari Australian GP Carlos Sainz Jnr collided with Fernando Alonso Failed
2/7/2023 McLaren Canadian GP Lando Norris penalised for unsportsmanlike driving Failed
9/11/2023 Haas United States GP Track limits breaches Failed
5/5/2024 Aston Martin Chinese GP Fernando Alonso collided with Carlos Sainz Jnr Failed
26/10/2024 McLaren United States GP Lando Norris was penalised for overtaking Max Verstappen off the track Failed
13/9/2025 Williams Dutch GP Carlos Sainz Jnr was penalised for colliding with Liam Lawson Succeeded

NB. ‘Right of Review’ requests are different to ‘protests’

This article will be updated

Miss nothing from RaceFans

Get a daily email with all our latest stories – and nothing else. No marketing, no ads. Sign up here:

2026 Monaco Grand Prix

Browse all 2026 Monaco Grand Prix articles

Related posts

Round-up: FIA’s ADUO deems Red Bull-Ford top combustion engine, and more

Rivals’ moves were “borderline unacceptable” says Sainz after Hulkenberg’s penalty

Cadillac lose first points finish after Perez penalised, Alonso scores for Aston Martin

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Read More