Oliver Bearman says Formula 1’s racing guidelines created a “harsh scenario” after the stewards penalised him for a collision in the Italian Grand Prix.
The Haas driver is at risk of triggering an automatic race ban after moving onto a total of 10 penalty points for his collision with Carlos Sainz Jnr at Monza.
The collision occured as Sainz overtook Bearman on the outside heading into the Roggia chicane. The stewards ruled Bearman responsible because, under the terms of F1’s racing guidelines, he had lost the right to the racing line on the way into the corner. However Bearman says many people agree his penalty was not fair.
“It’s annoying to be governed by these guidelines which I feel are quite vague in some areas and quite specific in others,” he told the official Formula 1 channel. “With my incident in Monza I felt like I was pretty hard done by.
“The guidelines state that I don’t deserve any space on the inside in that specific scenario, which in my view is a bit harsh. Of course, I’m biased towards myself, but I think a lot of people will agree and say that was quite a harsh scenario.”
Last week Williams successfully challenged a penalty Sainz received in the previous round at Zandvoort where the stewards also held him responsible for a collision which occured after he lost the right to the racing line. However Haas chose not to challenge Bearman’s penalty.
Bearman received two penalty points for the collision. If he picks up two more this weekend or in any of the next three rounds after it, he will trigger an automatic ban.
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and
“It’s definitely something that I have to take into account,” he said. “It’s a shame to be at this point, but I just have to have a few clean races.”
Oliver Bearman’s penalty points
| Date | Event | Session | Infringement | Points |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3/11/2024 | Brazilian Grand Prix | Grand prix | ‘Causing a collision with car 43 in turn 10.’ | 2 |
| 23/5/2025 | Monaco Grand Prix | Qualifying | ‘Car 87 overtook Car 55 under red flag.’ | 2 |
| 5/7/2025 | British Grand Prix | Third practice | ‘Failure to comply with a red flag’ | 4 |
| 7/9/2025 | Italian Grand Prix | Grand prix | ‘Car 87 collided with Car 55 at Turn 4’ | 2 |
You say
Did the stewards issue the correct penalty to Bearman at Monza? Cast your vote below and have your say in the comments.
Bearman’s penalty for his incident with Sainz was…
- No opinion (2%)
- Far too lenient (2%)
- Slightly too lenient (4%)
- Correct (16%)
- Slightly too harsh (18%)
- Far too harsh (58%)
Total Voters: 50
Miss nothing from RaceFans
Get a daily email with all our latest stories – and nothing else. No marketing, no ads. Sign up here:
2025 Azerbaijan Grand Prix
- First ever wet race in Baku possible this weekend – Alonso
- Hamilton expects Ferrari’s “softer” car will suit Baku better than Mercedes did
- Antonelli says Wolff was right to call his Italian GP “underwhelming”
- Bearman criticises “harsh” racing guidelines after moving close to ban at Monza
- “It’s a very tough place to be”: Lawson’s advice to Hadjar over Red Bull chance